Wednesday, 23 July 2008

Australian politicians (4): Bob Brown

An Australian hero of tree-huggers world-over, bĂȘte noire of tycoon and industrialist, this week's Australian politician is none other than Senator and Leader of the Australian Greens, Bob Brown. To say he represents minorities would be something of an understatement:
  • He represents the State of Tasmania, a small and largely irrelevant power when sitting around the negotiating table with the likes of New South Wales, Victoria and Queensland
  • He leads the Australia Greens, which in a country blessed with some of world's richest abundance of natural resources is always going to be a bit like pissing in the wind
  • He was also the first openly gay member of the Australian Parliament, again probably not something to naturally endear him to a nature of rugged, beer swilling Australian males
Anyhow, Bob Brown has a CV brimming with campaigning experience. Arrested nine times, he actually spent 16 days in jail following a famous, and ultimately successful, campaign to block the damming of the Franklin River. Bob’s anti-logging efforts managed to get him shot at and his car burned; his interruption of President George Bush’s Parliamentary address in 2003 earned him a suspension from the institution (ironically, it was a speech on the importance of Free Speech that he interrupted and was barred for).

Importantly, it turns out that Bob Brown’s Greens may now hold the key to Rudd pushing through Labor’s emission trading scheme. That’s come about because the Opposition Coalition are looking likely to withdraw their support – requiring Labor to turn to the Greens as the party holding the power balance in the Senate.

Will make for a very interesting few months, with the hysterics over petrol prices pushing for a watered down scheme negotiated with the Opposition. The politically smart move from the Greens would clearly be to head this off and move early and with open arms to Labor (and take a hit on some of the purity of things). Something that fortunately doesn’t seem to have escaped Senator Bob Brown.

Tuesday, 15 July 2008

New cultures

At the weekend I went along to 'Queensland Roars Against Racism'. First on the bill was a celebrity football game followed by a match between the Brazilian team, Palmeiras, and Queensland's professional team, 'Roar'. The tickets were courtesy of local author, Nick Earls, who was playing in the celebrity game and is a friend of a friend.

Two observations from that night. First, that disappointingly football isn't really a world game after all. On a number of occasions the various celebrities - including players of aussie rules and rugby, TV stars, and musicians - had to be explained the basic rules of football like which part of the pitch you're allowed to stand in during kick off and how to do a throw in. And I'm not even allowed to call it 'football'.


Second, that there's a whole popular cultural history in Australia that I've never come across. Of course each country has its own cultural stock of people and events. But what's slowly dawned on me is that I know almost nothing about the popular cultural history of this place -- save for perhaps the Minogues, Germaine Greer, Clive James, Harry Kewell, Nicole Kidman, and the present and past cast of Neighbours.

Indeed I can only ever remember hearing about three news stories relating to Australia in my entire life (which were the American scuba divers left behind by their boat and presumably eaten by sharks, the beauty therapist jailed in Indonesia for drug carrying and causing outcry across Australia, and the Cape York rape case).

Before arriving here I wouldn't have been able to name (certainly without prompting) a single band, author, painter, playwriter, politician, film maker or actor actually living and working in Australia.


Just as an example of things over the last week alone, is it just me that has never heard of the chart topping band Powderfinger, the motor racing 'legend' Peter Brock, the classic comedy film The Castle, the eclectic and popular painter Sidney Nolan, and for that matter the bestselling author Nick Earls??



Aussie beers (2)

Was about to do another blog on Aussie beers and then came across this news story. Darwin resident Michael Leary was spending $1,100 a week on beer, supposedly equivalent to 27 'slabs' per week. (A slab is a case of 24 beers, so that would be over 600 beers a week. Clearly something wrong with the maths here, probably a bit of exageration and him drinking at bars rather than by 4-caseload at home every night. Still, impresive.)

The absolute best bit, however, is the quote from the magistrate:

''(That is) poor judgement on two counts there - drinking that much and drinking Melbourne Bitter''.

I'll try to source some for review in the next beer blog...

Thursday, 10 July 2008

Federalism

One thing I hadn’t quite anticipated before coming to Queensland is the depth of wrangling between State and Commonwealth governments. I perhaps also thought that even if things have been tense at other times, it’d be much smoother with Labor governments now in power at all levels. Not so.

The heart of the issue is at which level should sit various policy responsibilities. For example, on health policy the Commonwealth pay for GPs and primary care, the States for community care and public health with consequential challenges particularly around coorindation, funding, and accountability. In the debate about what sits where I find myself increasingly siding with the Commonwealth.

It’s again a hot topic following an impassioned speech by Queensland’s Premier Anna Bligh billed as a ‘spirited defence of federalism’. It’s definitely worth a read, even though it contained some bad along with the good.

The Bad

  • A good use of the ‘subsidiarity principle’ (i.e. that power should sit at the most local level possible) but needs more detail on the underlying rationale. I also believe in subsidiarity though could equally use it to construct an argument for aggregation e.g. with the various tests I previously posted. And, perhaps ironically, other advocates of subsidiarity might note it’s a strong argument for devolving power to local agencies and bypass states altogether.

  • A number of dodgy factual claims. The worst offender of which is the statement that ‘Federated structures like Australia … have higher rates of per capita GDP’. (Note this isn’t a claim that one causes the other, but it’s certainly intended to imply that.) I read the research report on which this was based on and what the analysis used is a simple comparison of average per capita GDP in federal countries (i.e. US, Switzerland, Australia) compared to unitary systems (i.e. UK, France etc). Pretty ridiculous really.

  • Some select interpretations on global trends. For example, Bligh says ‘let’s acknowledge the global trend towards federalism’. No, let’s not. What seems to be happening is a slow but steady trend for more complex, multi-faceted and tiered governance arrangements but not really in what could be called federalist in the sense of multiple layers within the same political system. For example, aggregating some functions up to higher levels like the EU and major international institutions, devolving others down.

The Good

  • The concept of exchange of responsibilities. A bargaining between State and Commonwealth levels about which responsibilities should sit where will help ensure the process is thoughtful rather than a simple power-grab.

  • Application to education, health, and climate change. It makes the debate real and has put some issues on the table for debate.

  • Excellent timing and thoughtful contribution to the debate that’s put Queensland in a lead position in negotiations over the next 6 months or so.

Tuesday, 8 July 2008

Australian Politicians (3): Bob Hawke

The latest distinctively Australian politician I’ve discovered is a former Prime Minister by the name of Bob Hawke. The Labour PM between 1983 and 1991, he was eventually usurped from within by Paul Keating.

His major policy achievements included:
  • Some substantial economic reform included financial deregulation, dismantling of trade tariffs, and floating of the Australian dollar

  • Establishing Australia’s Medicare system of social insurance (or rather re-establishing under a different name the ‘Medibank’ system abolished by the Liberals)

  • Some early moves on Aboriginal affairs
Trumping all of these however was a much earlier achievement of Hawke’s while at University. It turns out he held a Guinness World Record no less for being the world’s fastest beer consumer, gulping down a yard of ale in 11 seconds.

Hawke later claimed this enviable boozing feat was the single most important factor in contributing to his later political success, endearing him forever to a nation of beer lovers.

Only in Australia…

Sunday, 6 July 2008

Industrial policy in the Gold Coast

I spent the weekend travelling along and around the 'Gold Coast' to the south of Brisbane. The 60km coast receives over four million visitors per year, to see not just the great beaches but also the whole host of tourist attractions such as the Florida style Warner Bros Movie World and Sea World theme parks.

Perhaps the most famous part is a resort known today as 'Surfers Paradise'. It's a glizy and glam place, with the skyline lit up by a multitude of casinos, shopping malls and nightclubs. But it wasn't always like this. Indeed the town formerly known as Elston was still a very rural, remote and largely unvisited town as late as the 1950s.

So what's the secret to transforming a small and insigificant seaside town into one of Australia's major tourist hubs? Targeted capital tax breaks? Relaxed planning laws? Investment in infrastructure?

Apparently not. Instead it was down to the ingenuity of local entrepreneur Bernie Elsey who, in 1965, decided to employ 'meter maids' in gold lamé bikinis to feed the parking meters along the strip. People soon flocked to Surfers Paradise where, rather than have militant parking wardens dole out fines, they would find glamous young girls to feed their meter for them and, if they returned late, leave a calling card for them to pay later.

The region has never looked back. (Actually part of the explanation was also the building of road and rail links, a couple of risky but eventually profitable high rise developments and massive investment in marketing campaigns, though that all sounds a bit too boring).







Thursday, 3 July 2008

Anna Bligh and Political Personalities

Having a mind that unfortunately only starts working when there’s something to analyse or contrast I tend to think of politicians falling into various shapes and guises. For example:


  • The ‘Fire-fighter’: the type of politician who only gets energy when dealing with crises, or when thrown into some bitter public dispute. This animal thrives on confrontation and quarrel and is a master of political tricks and deception. John Reid and David Blunkett come to mind.

  • The ‘Implementer’: the silent and unassuming type of politician who quietly gets on with implementing the commands of those more senior, building a reputation for robust but unimaginative delivery. Which makes a good basis for slow but steady progression through the ranks – Alastair Darling’s a perfect example.

  • The ‘Big-tenter’: the politician who strives to canvass a wide range of views and build consensus. Tends to be viewed as nice but indecisive, and probably not destined for the big portfolios. Hillary Benn perhaps?

  • The ‘Party loyalist’: the politician who likes to be seen as the one with their ear closest to the party’s grassroots and a champion of the views of the man in the street. Likely to play a key bridging role between policy and party (and the accompanying baggage) and be a solid and immovable character. John Prescott played this role for almost two decades.

  • The ‘Planter-shaper’: the big-picture ideas and problem-solving type of politician who develops a reputation for having the most creative and unorthodox ideas. This is a high-risk, high-return strategy and the fastest route to the top if played well. The two Millibands and Purnell are probably the best current UK examples.

  • The ‘Investigator-Evaluator’: the scrutinising type of politician, always with a keen eye on finding new ways of operating. An analytical animal by nature, the investigator-evaluator politician scans for best-practice though perhaps with a view more to improving existing policy practices than the more fundamental ‘questioning the question’ type strategy role.

  • The ‘Specialist’: a rare breed of politician, one who is a technical expert in their field and has generally has high levels of professional credibility. Lord Darzi perhaps falls in this category; Ivan Lewis has been cultivating a similar reputation in social care over recent years.

  • The ‘Controller-dictator’: one of the worst types of politicians whose lust for power can result in controlling tendencies, monitoring all they command and control. Unfortunately, and most tragically, this can sometimes be without a reason why.

I’ve seen Queensland’s Premier Anna Bligh in action a few times now and I must say she’s an impressive politician. Probably a combination of the 'investigator-evaluator', 'big-tenter' and 'implementer' it’s driving a real cultural shift in the public service here towards more serious long term policy and planning. By all accounts this is in marked contrast to the previous – and successful – Premier, Peter Beattie, who I’m told fell more into the ‘fire-fighter’ camp.